Recipe-based restaurant cohort study - how they nailed the sprouts


The Robert Koch Institute explains how they nailed the sprouts..
Recipe-based restaurant cohort study
(italics and bolding added)
"With a high probability, the results of the „recipe-based restaurant cohort study” finally permit narrowing down the source of the infection to the consumption of sprouts. It was possible to apply this methodological approach only after a sufficient number of restaurant customers could be identified to ensure adequate statistical power of this analysis.
To ascertain the consumption of raw fruit and vegetables by patients and controls more objectively and less dependently on memory, RKI used the following approach in the “recipe-based restaurant cohort study”: Five groups (travel groups, clubs, etc) that comprised a total of 112 participants and included 19 individuals who acquired EHEC infection were questioned regarding the foods they consumed after eating in a common restaurant. Additionally, the menus ordered by the participants were identified by means of order lists and meal receipts. The restaurant kitchen was questioned in detail regarding the preparation and the type and quantity of ingredients in each menu ordered by any of the study participants. Furthermore, available photographs taken by travel group members were analysed to confirm which food items, including toppings, were seen on the plates. The data thus gathered was analysed in a cohort approach that permits the retrospective estimation of the relative risk of infection for the restaurant customers. Results of this analysis showed that customers who ate sprouts had an 8.6-fold increased risk (95% confidence interval (CI) 1.5-∞) of EHEC/HUS illness compared to those who did not. This study also revealed that 100% of those who contracted the illness had eaten sprouts."
Insights from case-control-studies regarding the consumption of sprouts

"Patients were questioned on the consumption of a large number of animal and plant origin food products, including sprouts, in the initial intensive exploratory interviews in Hamburg on May 20 and 21. In these, only 3 of 12 patients reported having eaten sprouts. Moreover, a relevant under-ascertainment of sprout consumption seemed unlikely since the participants of this survey demonstrated an exceptionally high dietary awareness. Methodological standards in outbreak investigations call for inclusion of those exposures in the standardized questionnaires that can potentially explain a high proportion of outbreak cases. The inclusion of too many potential exposures may lead to false positive associations. For these reasons, sprouts were not included in the questionnaires of the initial case control studies. Later, more extensive interviews subsequently conducted by RKI again included the consumption of sprouts. Overall, 16 (30%) of 54 patients who could answer questions on the consumption of sprouts in the context of these extensive interviews stated having eaten sprouts within the time frame consistent with the period of acquisition of the infection."

Comments

Post a Comment

Your comments are so welcome!

Popular posts from this blog

Scratchy throat?

Image
Tip of the day: Try some pastilles My throat was a little scratchy this morning, so I sucked on a blackcurrant pastille (Cassis Pastilles) . They are a wonderful chewy consistency - nothing like the hard candy type of cough drop/throat lozenge we have here in the US. A few years ago, scratchy throats were going around a workshop I attended in Germany. My wonderful German roommate got me a box of Ricola Krauterpastillen (Blackcurrent Pastilles). They are so great for a sore throat. We have Ricola cough drops here in America, but no pastilles. Pity.
Read more

Euro - USD - Euro - USD

Tip of the day: Consider the Travelex Prepaid Currency Cash Passport Card Back in the day, carrying Traveler's Cheques was the way to go to Europe. Many countries, many different currencies. N o l o n g e r t h e c a s e . Now, for Western Europe you need the Euro, Swiss Francs for Switzerland, and the Pound for England. There is alot of info on the internet about money and travel to Europe (use ATMs, make sure you have a 4 digit pin, take a credit card with low to no surcharge for foreign transactions). I am going to tell you what worked for us in July 2009. The Travelex Cash Passport. If you load $2500 USD onto the Cash Passport, you'll get a better USD-Euro exchange rate than the current counter rate. We used the card in stores, restaurants, and at ATMs to withdraw Euros. It was smooth and easy. The card offers protection in case it is lost or stolen. My daughter and I each carried a card that linked to same account so we could move separately and have access to
Read more

Velib Paris

Image
Tip of the day: To see Paris by bicycle, get a credit card with a chip I had heard about the Paris Velib bicycle system on a radio show and was eager to try it out. http://www.npr.org/templates/story/story.php?storyId=14429468 . This bicycle system was attributed with making Paris more friendly. The Velib bikes stood out and could not be missed - long racks of bicycles near the great tourist destinations, Parisians picking up bikes, dropping them off at the racks, tourists and citizens riding around the city. At this point I was ready give my feet a rest and cover some ground on a bike. We looked bewilderedly at the rental kiosk at the rack we happened upon. Then a kind citizen gave a half hour explanation (in French) to Kurt -our Swiss travel companion, guide, friend, and linguist. Kurt said "she tells me you need to have a chip in your credit card to place the deposit on the bicycle." Air rushes out leaving me deflated like a balloon smashed empty on the sidewalk. B
Read more